Shopping Cart Link

Brandeis University Press

Sign up for our newsletter

Bookmark and Share
Cart link
Cover image

Women, Birth, and Death in Jewish Law and Practice
Rochelle L. Millen

HBI Series on Jewish Women

2004 • 264 pp. 6 x 9"
Jewish Studies

Sorry—this item is Out of Print

"This clearly written book makes a useful contribution to the growing body of literature on women in Judaism . . . As Millen discusses different life cycle events, she incorporates her own experiences as a Jewish woman. In so doing, she adds a compelling and intimate dimension to this fine work of scholarship. Recommended."Choice

A sensitive exploration of the development of pivotal life cycle rituals as they touch Jewish women’s lives.

The past twenty-five years have seen the development of rich literature on Judaism and feminism. Some studies have examined rituals related to the feminine within a religious context; others have read rabbinic sources through feminist lenses. Most recently, scholars have had a heightened interest in the life experiences that help define the identity of a woman as female. These uniquely female aspects of human development assume special significance when they are put in the context of the Jewish life-cycle and the underlying issues of feminism that impact upon them.

Rochelle Millen’s book, a crucial addition to this literature, explores how Jewish tradition perceives and treats rituals surrounding birth and death, particularly as they pertain to women’s development. Following a substantial introduction in which she discusses her methodology and lays out key themes, Millen turns in Part I to birth contraception and birth control, fertility, and celebrating the birth of a daughter (the ritual of Simhat bat). Part II comprises chapters on the kaddish, or the memorial prayer for the dead, and the funeral. Each chapter begins with an elegant synthesis of rabbincal views on the role of women in the ritual under scrutiny. Millen draws on halakhic literature from modern Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform Judaism, with sensitivity to the different guidelines given to diverse communities within distinct historical periods.

Following this overview, she richly contextualizes the legal debates by raising questions about gender and sexuality and through exploring the public/private nexus and community/autonomy dialectic as understood by different Jewish denominations. As Millen points out, it is the intersection of these "four polarities" within religious and halakhic Judaism that poses a profound challenge to women’s roles in Judaism and also to the very vitality of Judaism itself. A brief epilogue illuminates the contemporary challenge for all Jewish denominations to integrate Jewish women into these primary life-cycle rituals.

Combining personal, legal, philosophical, and feminist critiques, this volume not only analyzes the rites of birth and death—their components and traditional meanings—but also explores new, halakhically-sanctioned forms of celebration and commemoration for contemporary Jewish women.

Click here for TABLE OF CONTENTS

Reviews / Endorsements

"This is a deeply scholarly book, yet very readable . . . This book provides a great deal of information and will cause its readers to think and rethink their own positions."Jewish Book World

“[T]his book is to be highly recommended. It is meticulously researched and peppered with thoughtful insights. In sum, it is a valuable research tool for those interested in birth and death in the Jewish tradition.”Shofar: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Jewish Studies

Women, Birth and Death in Jewish Law and Practice contributes to the growing literature on feminism and Judaism by demonstrating how the concepts of gender, sexuality, public/private and community/autonomy are essential concepts of modernity and of the rabbinic discourse that is the foundation of all manifestations of Judaism.”Menorah Review"Millen’s scholarship is excellent and the author, well-read in Jewish, general feminist, and philosophical literature, is in full command of her sources. But it is the deeply felt emotional experiences of Millen as a Jewish woman committed to living a halakhic way of life that trigger her commitment to this exploration of birth and death rituals as they touch women's lives. Her book's smooth blending of scholarship introduced and "justified" by personal experience gives it its special flavor. An impressive synthesis of the personal, legal, and feminist approaches, this volume will engage readers who are knowledgeable about Jewish law and those who are just beginning to explore the subject."Rela Mintz Geffen, President, Baltimore Hebrew University

ROCHELLE L. MILLEN is Professor of Religion at Wittenberg University, Springfield, Ohio.

Tue, 11 Jul 2017 09:43:10 -0500